Lucas Torreira’s Midfield Tackle: Is There a Foul?
Bulent Yildirim:I think a foul and yellow card should have been given in this position.
Bahattin Duran:Torreira’s intention was clearly to play the ball. If this position had resulted in a goal, the referee would definitely turn around. This is a foul on the opponent and a yellow card should definitely have been shown.
Sea Shepherd:We agree that this intervention was a clear foul and should have resulted in a yellow card.
Tackle on Torreira in the Penalty Area: Penalty?
Bulent Yildirim:This position is a clean tackle in my opinion.
Bahattin Duran:The player is clearly interfering with the ball. There is no violation by the Hatay player here.
Sea Shepherd:The Hatay player got the timing right. If he had made a mistake in his timing, it could have been a penalty.
Abdulkerim’s Intervention Against His Opponent and Davinson’s Hand Gesture
Bulent Yildirim:I don’t believe Davinson’s move was directed at the referee. I think it was directed at Barış Alper.
Bahattin Duran:The action by Abdülkerim was definitely a clear foul and he should have shown a yellow card here. I think Davinson’s hand gesture towards the referee also warranted a yellow card.
Sea Shepherd:This position is clearly a foul and a yellow card. I don’t think Davinson’s action was directed at the referee, but in such a situation the referee should also give a yellow card.
Derrick Köhn’s Move Against His Opponent: Is a Red Card Necessary?
Bulent Yildirim:I don’t see any violent action here. However, it is unacceptable not to give a yellow card in such a position.
Bahattin Duran:Köhn waves his hand clearly. This move should have resulted in a yellow card. If he had clenched his fist or elbowed the ball, I would definitely expect a red card. However, this play should not have gone unnoticed; it should have been given.
Sea Shepherd:For me, this position is not a classic red card. If the referee has seen a violent action, then there is a foul. But here a yellow card would have been enough and unfortunately the referee missed the yellow card.
Penalty Won by Galatasaray
Bulent Yildirim:There is contact with the foot here and this is a clear penalty. The referee should have shown the Hatay player a yellow card.
Bahattin Duran:In order for there to be no penalty, the Hatay player should have intervened cleanly. However, the Hatay player does not intervene in this case. When Icardi sees his opponent coming, he puts himself forward and the Hatay player intervenes in a very clear way. I think there is a clear penalty here.
Sea Shepherd:A referee who calls a penalty at this level should definitely give a yellow card. I find the penalty decision to be correct. The player who objected to the referee should also have been punished with a yellow card. While Icardi has the ball in front of him, the opposing player interferes with his support leg. You have no such right; there is a clear penalty decision here.
Was Batshuayi’s Goal Offside?
Bahattin Duran:While Berkan Kutlu sends the ball in, Batshuayi is offside. For offside, he either needs to touch the ball or affect the player who touches the ball. We see that he did not interfere with the ball, but here the player is affected. In my opinion, Batshuayi interfered with his opponent while he was in an offside position. VAR does not intervene in this position.
Bulent Yildirim:Here, the assistant referee on the field will make the offside decision. According to the assistant referee, he preferred to play the ball because it fell further back. This position varies from person to person. If I were on the field, it would be offside for me too. But if the assistant has no doubts, the VAR cannot call the referee unless a clear decision is made.
Sea Shepherd:The distance between the two players is important, but here it should not be affected because the two players are in contact. I think the Hatay player had to fight with two Galatasaray players. I think Batshuayi affects the Hatayspor player. In this case, there is offside. However, VAR does not interfere here.
